which one is more effect the game Blade or Rubber?

Performance depends on what the player values and how the equipment suits their game.

Also like a few or others that do tibhar aurus is meant for backhand or just a all around rubber. I've used those types of rubbers for forehand and have had no problem. So no matter the blade even with cheaper or not high speed rating rubbers I still played well. Nexy elips, demeian, aurus/soft/sound, sriver/g3/fx/el, etc can all be used on most blades if not all. So to be honest the blade really doesn't do much except help with whatever style of player you are. Flat hitters and smashers need stiff to really hard blades vs too soft and it doesn't do much
Also forgot to mention I have 729 focus 3 snipe both sides only available in 2.1 well all that I know of currently I'm using it my other long 3 and I realized I kind of spent more money on gewo when 729 gets the job done just fine. High spin and fast blocks give me an ease of mind also don't need to do a hyper form or extension to get power or spin. But not everyone has the same body or form so results will vary.

Edited by HarmonicTT - 09/10/2017 at 12:30am

Question for those who currently use a top end alc or zlc blade.. what blade would go down to if you are forced to, and why?

Do you think it would affect your game if you can still have your choice of rubbers?

Sorry maybe the question is not fully understood because my English is so bad (I always use Google translate)
I mean only Is blade more important or is rubber more important?
if we have a old cheap blade but have a tenergy 05 how is our game effect?
or if we have zhang jike süper zlc but have a tıbhar rapid soft how is our game effect? (if all other variables are the same...same time same person etc.. )
   

Rubber unless your using long pips with no sponge or .5 1.0 1.5 then the blade does make a difference as well as the pips.

From personal experience, the blades are more important than rubbers . I used the same type of rubbers on 2 different blades and one racket bounced much more than the other !


Edited by mike1250 - 09/10/2017 at 7:45pm

For me, blades. 

mike1250 wrote: From personal experience, the blades are more important than rubbers . I used the same type of rubbers on 2 different blades and one racket bounced much more than the other !

From experience I will have to say that it took me more time and effort to adapt to a new blade than it does to a new rubber.

LUCKYLOOP wrote: That is strange, the ball drop with no force doesn't even penetrate the rubber.... .

Strange or not , you have no choice but accepting this fact : the only difference between the 2 cases is the different blades . So , it must be due to the blades.

1.  Take the blade of your choice, whatever you like, it doesn't matter.  Put Tenergy 05, or Hurricane unboosted, or Mark V on it, and in each case it will play totally differently.  You will need to use different racket angles on almost every shot, depending on the rubber.  If you are used to any one of those and switch to the other you will find yourself knocking the ball off the table or into the net for a long time.  (By contrast, switch from Tenergy 05 to Evolution MX-P and you will adjust much more easily).  The rubber matters.

2.  Now take, say, a Butterfly Viscaria and a Donic Appelgren Allplay (or a Stiga All Around).  Put Tenergy 05 on each one.  Again you will find that you will need quite distinct changes in technique to play, and adjustment is far from instantaneous  But if you put Tenergy 05 on a Viscaria or a Donic True Carbon, not much difference based on those blades, assuming you stick with same handle shape.  You can adjust very easily, even though no two blades are identical.  The blade matters.

3.  In an case, the only way to figure out if you like a blade/rubber combination is by trying it.  The cheapest way to do that is to try other people's blades.  You can waste a lot of money trying blades or rubbers based on what you read on the internet.  Some people don't mind that, it is part of the fun for them, but if money is an issue, heed my words.

Yes but two sheets of some rubbers cost more than many blades!

LUCKYLOOP wrote: What is the total weight of each paddle, including blade and rubber ?

For Blade + Rubbers :

Yinhe/Galaxy N-9s :  181. gr
Kokutaku (5 ply wood )  : 184. gr

Sounds way too much difference with same rubber. It's simple physics, the bouncing is affected first by the elasticity, tension, of the rubber, any blade is orders of magnitude more rigid than any rubber, and will mostly affect the vibrations damping or not. If you are swinging very fast, you could have difference due to the weight, and you could start to see more effect of the bat rigidity, but just bouncing the ball.... I would say probably a problem with the test protocol, inconsistent application of the rubbers, or variance in ther rubber (have you tried swapping rubbers)

Blade is related: fast or slow (speed), stiff or flex (stiff better for block & flex better to loop), hard & soft (hard to drive & attack & soft to defend).